Each Smart Search (except for Miscellaneous) is divided in two sections, Duplicate and Similar.
If a search is selected in this section, Tidy Up will include in the criteria of that search the comparison by the content of files, byte by byte; the result will therefore contain only true duplicates.
The searches in this section don’t include the comparison; the result therefore won’t contain true duplicates, but instead similar files.
To quickly visualize the criteria in detail of a search, click on the info button beside the search.